

THE SUPREME Court bench headed by Chief Justice Surya Kant in its order on September 3, made a categorical observation that Bar Council of India or State Bar Councils have no power or authority whatsoever under the Advocates Act, 1961, to exercise any disciplinary action against law students before the completion of their studies and registration as lawyers. It unequivocally stated the legal and constitutional position that the matters concerning acts of commission and omission of students pursuing law in universities or any educational institution fall exclusively within the jurisdiction of the authorities mandated to run such institutions.
The SC bench did so while hearing a petition of NALSAR students against BCI Chairman Manan Kumar Mishra's now-withdrawn order that the entire 2026 batch of students NALSAR University of Law, Hyderabad, should not be enrolled with State Bar Councils as lawyers and action should be taken against the erring students.
Illegal Order of Mishra
He issued that order and justified it on the ground that on July 23 a group of graduating students from the NALSAR had the temerity to write to their university administration not to invite justice Surya Kant for the convocation citing their grave concerns over his handling of a plea related to alleged police brutalities against protesters at Jantar Mantar and his stern refusal even to watch video clips capturing peaceful protestors helplessly confronting the coercive action taken by security forces against them.