Indira Jaising

| @IJaising | August 28,2018

Lawyer Surendra Gadling successfully defending his clients under the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act (UAPA) was arrested and thrown behind bars since June 6 of this year. Now lawyer Susan Abraham defending Gadling in Pune has seen her house in Mumbai raided and her husband Vernon Gonsalves arrested. Vernon has earlier faced prosecution under UAPA and was acquitted after spending over five years in prison. Today, he has been arrested again. Sudha Bharadwaj, a prominent trade unionist and academic, has been arrested and will be taken to Pune, as per latest reports. Her 20-year-old daughter has had her Facebook accounts locked and her electronic devices confiscated.

Other activists whose homes were raided include Stan Swamy in Ranchi, Arun Ferreira in Mumbai, Gautam Navlakha in Delhi, Anand Teltumbade in Goa, And Vara Vara Rao, daughter Ananla and son-in-law Kamalnath in Hyderabad. Some of them have also been arrested as I write these painful words.

Susan, Shoma (Sen) and Sudha are all mothers bringing up their children sons and daughters peacefully. They are all professional working women, law-abiding citizens who uphold our constitutional morality to the last letter. Today, they are either behind bars, or are witnessing their homes being invaded by the State.

Why? What’s their crime? To represent the country’s Dalits? Muslims? Adivasis? Women? The disenfranchised and dispossessed? Is that why they are being branded as “Urban Naxals”, “Half Maoists” — by not only members of the ruling party, including eminent ministers, but also by sections of the TV, digital and social media? Are these arrests the draconian fallout of those words, those narratives playing over and over again during prime time on our national television?

Susan, Shoma (Sen) and Sudha are all mothers bringing up their children sons and daughters peacefully. They are all professional working women, law-abiding citizens who uphold our constitutional morality to the last letter. Today, they are either behind bars, or are witnessing their homes being invaded by the State

On August 14, I was invited to the launch of a book published by Oxford University Press. Edited by Abhishekh Manu Singhivi, it was a compilation of the writings of his late father Dr L M Singhvi. Among the invited guests were former President Pranab Mukherjee and Union Minister Nitin Gadkari. The eminent panel was being moderated by senior journalist Karan Thapar. When Thapar asked about the issue of Union Cabinet minister Jayant Sinha’s public garlanding of those accused in lynching cases and questioned what Gadkari’s party, the ruling BJP, had to say abut that, Gadkari’s answer was that the party was not aware of who all was garlanding whom and who was getting photographed with whom. As Thapar pressed on — “but he is our minister” — Gadari replied: “In this country, there is no guilt by association”, thereby indirectly justifying Sinha’s garlanding men accused of the targeted hate crime.

Everyone kept quiet. There was no challenge to him. On the contrary, people clapped and exclaimed how charming he was.

I put my hand up and when my turn came, I asked: “You say there is no guilt by association. Yet your ministers call us ‘Half Maoists’ —  a new cuss word for us, and we are held guilty by association. Can you explain that to me?” Gadkari then said: “Yes I am aware that something has happened in Nagpur, there have been arrests. If it’s only by association, it should not happen.”

I asked Union Minister Nitin Gadkari: “You say there is no guilt by association. Yet your ministers call us ‘Half Maoists’ —  a new cuss word for us, and we are held guilty by association. Can you explain that to me?”

Now I feel his words were ominous. Is the government trying hard to prove that there is an actual “role” to justify the initial arrests? What have we come to? Are we a country which arrests its lawyers first to prevent them from defending their already vulnerable and marginalised client-citizens?

Every human being has a right to a legal defence.

We are going through times when lawyers who are on the front lines taking up unpopular causes are being maligned, attacked, arrested and held in prolonged detention, and/or even killed. If this does not stop, one day there will be no one to defend the rule of law, since there will be no rule of law to defend.

Also read: Thoughts on Independence Day: My family had home in Karachi, will I too be asked to go back to Pakistan?

Also read: Targeting of lawyers, dissenters is going on with impunity. Who says this isn’t Emergency?

5
Leave a Reply

avatar
5 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
2 Comment authors
PRADIP BISWASRamakrishnan Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Ramakrishnan
Guest
Ramakrishnan

If the opposition with 69% are mute and actionless, this society will have to see many horrors. In our democracy rulers and opposition have their share.

trackback

[…] A version of this article was first published on the Leaflet. […]

PRADIP BISWAS
Guest
PRADIP BISWAS

Susan, Shoma (Sen) and Sudha are all mothers bringing up their children sons and daughters peacefully. The narrative is tragic and dismal This is time rime we fought back such anarchism imposed on Activists of Civil Rights in India. How long this mayhem will continue!!! India is not BJP!!! And BJP is not INDIA!!!, People have the right to know and fire back!!! We are not afraid of confrontation!!! PRADIP BISWAS, FILM CRITIC.

PRADIP BISWAS
Guest
PRADIP BISWAS

HOOT OUT BJP!! THROW OUT ANARCHIST GOVT. INDIANS NEED FREEDOM SUCH POLITICAL CHAOS!!! PRADIP BISWAS, FILM CRITIC.

Also Read

Ambedkar's feminism

September 18,2018

Azadi for LGBTQI communities

September 8,2018

Mother like no other

September 7,2018

Why Article 35A matters

August 15,2018

Challenges beyond 377

August 13,2018

A positive beginning

August 10,2018

WSS condemn transphobia

August 6,2018

Blame it on Collegium

August 5,2018

Scroll Up