Indira Jaising

| @IJaising | August 15,2018

I too am one of Midnight’s Children.

Having been born before Independence, memories of Partition are alive in my mind, and so are the stories we had heard from our parents who migrated to the new-born Indian nation-state as refugees from what overnight became Pakistan.

We are the children of refugees.

I remember vividly my home in Karachi, now in Pakistan, and have often longed for the home of my childhood.

Here in India, I have at times felt stateless. States are organised on linguistic lines and we Sindhis have no state to call our own (at least judging from the same parameter, language).

Having no linguistic state, while being a limitation, is also deeply liberating. It tells me that allegiance, a sense of belonging, that feeling at the core of our very souls — that does not come from Statehood and Language alone.

It has been often said that the 21st century is the Century of Refugees. Refugees of displacement due to so-called development, refugees of religious hatred, of political rejection forced to seek asylum, the prisoners of conscience, of “illegal immigrations” across tyrannical, inhumane borders, refugees escaping terrorist and military regimes, climate and disaster refugees. The list just goes on and on.

My life has been a long struggle (some would say battle) in the court of law, but sometimes when I hear our ruling politicians say, “Muslims must go back to Pakistan where they came from“ — I wonder if I too will be asked to “go back home”,since I too once came from across the border.

And then I realise: But I was born a Hindu. So where is my home?  Will I too be asked to “go back home”, or will I be spared because my parents were Hindu refugees who migrated to India in the wake of Partition?

It is now for the fist time in 73 years that I am made to remember by Hindu origins from across the border.

But there is no comfort in it, only pain for the Republic of India, which is in danger of losing its secular foundational principles, its birth-pangs of great ideals, of pluralism and inter-faith harmony.

Will I be happy in a Hindu Republic? No. I will be forever living with an “enemy” or the “Other”—constructed by law not by life.

Law is not meant to construct identity; it is meant to respect identity.

At age 73, the age of the Indian Republic, I can only offer a defence of the secular Constitution of India with my own experience of having lived a moderately happy life … until now.

Leave a Reply

8 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
6 Comment authors
Rahul SinghgmybirdA.K.S.Kavita SrivastavaNilesh Ukey Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Notify of




Nilesh Ukey
Nilesh Ukey

Thanks for sharing a part of your life with us.

Kavita Srivastava
Kavita Srivastava

What is happening in Assam in the name of the NRC and what is happening to Muslims in this country makes one weep. Cry thy beloved country.


Indira Ji,
I am admirer of you and many more like you, who are fighting a tough battle to regain Indian Constitutional values. I have more faith in women, students and farmers and am highly disappointed with the ‘Degree Holder’ middle class.
Hope efforts of all of you will bring change.
Keep writing,


Madam, Please be unperturbed by the fringe talks. You will not be disappointed. The very fact that Secularism was chosen, embraced, promoted and patronized so far by the sane majority of Hindus also in this country, shall ensure the feeling of security in all people. Hinduism is as good or even may be better than secularism, with their hall marks of ‘Sarve Jana Sukhino Bhavanthu and Vasudaiva Kutumbakam’

Rahul Singh
Rahul Singh

Thought provoking


[…] Also read: Thoughts on Independence Day: My family had home in Karachi, will I too be asked to go b… […]

Also Read

Collegium - Prey to Judges

January 18,2019

The Right to Truth

January 11,2019

Trapped in a rat-hole

January 11,2019

Free Speech in India 2018

December 31,2018

Grave systemic injustice

December 31,2018

Change of tack for Maoists

December 11,2018

Understanding Criminal Law

December 7,2018

#MeToo: A tracker

November 29,2018

Pollution: Law isn't enough

November 27,2018

Raw deal for workers

November 27,2018

After #MeToo, beyond POSH

November 13,2018

Who was Justice Holmes?

October 23,2018

In pursuit of justice

October 9,2018

Humanity deported

October 6,2018

A liberal court

October 3,2018

Ambedkar's feminism

September 18,2018

Azadi for LGBTQI communities

September 8,2018

Mother like no other

September 7,2018

Why Article 35A matters

August 15,2018

Challenges beyond 377

August 13,2018

A positive beginning

August 10,2018

WSS condemn transphobia

August 6,2018

Blame it on Collegium

August 5,2018

Scroll Up