

SOMETIMES, THE WISEST THING in a courtroom isn’t a sharp question, or a powerful statement from either side. It is knowing which words were left unsaid — but were still profound. Because a judge’s words do not just decide cases; they can echo far beyond the courtrooms where they were spoken.
Oral observations made by a judge while presiding over cases can sometimes reveal the contours of the judge’s own thinkings, and beliefs. Yet, these remarks, especially if picked up by the media, can sometimes create unintentional public narratives that overshadow the actual legal merits of a case.
In the age of instant news, where “Breaking News” often “outruns the true understanding of the issue that’s adjudicated by the bench,” such comments are sometimes reported without full legal context. Ironically, the media’s amplification can magnify their impact far beyond what the judge intended.
In a recent matter, when Justice Dipankar Datta questioned the patriotism of Mr. Gandhi, the exchange quickly entered the public discourse, sparked debate well outside the courtroom, far away from the issue decided. In fact, the Bench accepted Mr. Gandhi’s counsel’s contention that the Lucknow Magistrate could not take cognisance of an offence without hearing Gandhi. Yet, it could not resist making “casual observations” such as:
“How do you know that 2000 sq. km was acquired by China? What is the credible material? A true Indian would not say this. When there is a conflict at the border, can you say such things? Why can’t you ask these questions in Parliament?”
None of these points were actually before the Bench for adjudication.