Women lawyers request CJI to direct removal of ‘objectionable’ video of former judge Karnan

SENIOR Advocate R Vaigai and other women lawyers from the Chennai Bar have written to the Chief Justice of India demanding action against former High Court Justice Karnan for his objectionable statements.

In a series of five videos, Justice Karnan is seen making threats of sexual assault against wives of thirteen sitting and former judges, and a former woman justice of the Supreme Court. He also goes on to make allegations of sexual assault against judges of Madras High Court, and in the process reveals the names of the victims.

The first video appeared on Whatsapp. Another set of four videos have been uploaded on Youtube. It is, at the moment, unclear whether the uploader is a lawyer or is in any way related to either the legal fraternity or to Justice Karnan himself.

Advocate S Devika, one of the signatories of the letter and who has been closely following the case, said “The captions of the videos intend to draw attention with the intention to malign the judges.”

The women lawyers are seeking immediate action to stop the circulation of these videos.

In the videos, Justice Karnan is seen threatening sexual assault on the wives of former and sitting Supreme Court justices. He also threatens physical violence against the judges themselves. He uses a racist remark of “calling Nelson Mandela’s people” to commit acts of violence against the judges.

He goes onto make grievous allegations of rape and sexual assault by judges of Madras High Court on women staff members, fellow female judges and law clerks. He also names the female victims and reveals their identities, which as the letter notes is a violation of the law.

“I have reported the videos to Youtube today morning and registered a formal complaint with them. A Senior Counsel who represents google has assured us that the matter will be looked into. I have also filed an online complaint with Cyber Crime Cell”, said Adv S. Devika.

Back in 2015, Justice Karnan had made allegations of sexual harassment of an intern by another sitting judge of Madras High Court but was unable to substantiate this with any evidence. In 2017, he became the first sitting High Court to be convicted of contempt of court. Justice Karnan has been embroiled in serious charges of corruption. He had in turn alleged caste discrimination and harassment by fellow judges.

The women lawyers in their letter note “Mr. Karnan, in the video, calls himself the foster son of Dr. Ambedkar. It is unfortunate that he should invoke the name of Dr. Ambedkar, who stood for egalitarian values and espoused the cause of gender justice. His reference to Dr. Ambedkar to valorise his threats not only denigrates the man and his remarkable work, but dilutes the cause of the less privileged.”


Read the letter