

THE CASE OF BILKIS BANO, who was gang-raped and lost all members of her family in the communal carnage in Gujarat in 2002, and whose three-and-a-half-year-old daughter was butchered to death before her eyes, has come to the fore once again.
Last month, a Bench comprising Justices M.M. Sundresh and P.B. Varale suspended the life sentences of two of the convicts, namely Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi @ Lala Doctor and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya. Both convicts have challenged the Bombay High Court’s orderof September 22, 2016.
As per the information available on the Supreme Court’s website, both convicts filed petitions on August 15, 2025, after a delay of close to nine years since the judgment was passed by the Bombay High Court. What explanation they offered for approaching the Court so belatedly is not in the public domain.
What is important to mention is that both the convicts were also part of the batch of convicts who were granted remission by the Gujarat Government with the approval of the Union Home Ministry in 2022, which a Bench of Justices B.V. Nagarathna and Ujjal Bhuyan quashed in 2024, finding it illegal.
The case status on the Court’s website under the “similarities” tab does not even refer to the decision passed by the Bench led by Justice Nagarathna.
On September 16, 2025, the petitions filed by convicts Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi @ Lala Doctor and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya came up for hearing before a Bench comprising Justices Rajesh Bindal and Prashant Kumar Mishra, when the matter was adjourned at the request of the counsel for the convicts. The Bench directed the matter to be listed on September 23, 2025.
From the record of the case, the matter does not appear to have been listed on September 23, 2025. It was instead listed on October 15, 2025, before a Bench comprising Justices Bindal and Manmohan. This time again, the matter was adjourned to November 10, 2025, at the request of the senior lawyer for the convicts.
On November 10, 2025, the matter was listed before a Bench comprising Justices Bindal and Manmohan. This time again, an adjournment was sought by the convicts to bring certain documents on record. The matter was adjourned to December 1, 2025.
On December 1, 2025, the matter was again listed before a Bench comprising Justices Bindal and Manmohan. Once again, the matter was adjourned to January 27, 2026, at the request of the counsel for the convicts.
From the record, it appears that the matter was not listed on January 27, 2026, but was listed on March 17, 2026, before a Bench comprising Justices Bindal and Vijay Bishnoi. This time Justice Manmohan was not on the Bench. The Bench condoned the delay in filing the petition, merely saying that the petitioners are in custody.
The Bench issued notice on the petitions. It recorded: “Inter alia, the argument raised by the learned counsel for the petitioners is that in the statement of the prosecutrix, she has not named the petitioners with the allegation of rape. Similar was her statement before the doctor at the time of medical examination. The only evidence remaining against the petitioners is that they may have been present in the mob at the time of the incident. No overt act has been attributed to them. Petitioner No. 1 is a physically disabled person. The petitioners have already undergone actual imprisonment of about 17 years. Issue notice to the respondents, returnable on 05.05.2026.”
The matter was not listed on May 5, 2026. Justice Bindal retired on April 15, 2026.
On September 22, 2026, the matter came up for hearing before a Bench comprising Justices K.V. Vishwanathan and Arun Palli. Justice Vishwanathan chose to recuse himself from the matter for reasons not available. The matter was directed to be listed before another Bench after taking orders from the Chief Justice of India.
On October 14, 2026, the matter came up before a Bench comprising Justices M.M. Sundresh and P.B. Varale, who directed the matter to be listed on October28, 2026, and ordered that the petitioners be permitted to serve a copy of the petition on the counsel for the CBI. The CBI was the investigating agency that probed the case.
On 28 October 2026, the matter came up before a Bench comprising Justices M.M. Sundresh and P.B. Varale, when the Bench granted bail to the two convicts.
The timeline indicates that the matter travelled through many Benches, and adjournment after adjournment was sought by the petitioners, especially when Justice Manmohan was on the Bench.
Although the petition was filed on August 15, 2025, and verified on September 12, 2025, notice was issued only on March 17, 2026, when the matter was before the Bench comprising Justices Bindal and Vijay Bishnoi. Before that, the matter had different puisne judges when adjournments were sought repeatedly.
All these months, the Bench did not point out the need to make Bilkis Bano a party to the case.
It is important to note that the Supreme Court in the past had dismissed appeals by co-convicts in the Bilkis Bano case.
Importantly, the Bench led by Justice Nagarathna, which quashed the en masse remission to the convicts, observed the nature of the crime committed against Bano as “grotesque and diabolical driven by communal hatred.”
The trajectory of the case raises the following questions:
• Why was Bilkis Bano not made a party to the case and heard before the ordering of suspension of sentence of the two convicts, when in law she was entitled to be heard?
• Why was there a nine-year delay in filing the SLP against the conviction when the grounds raised were well known and said to be a matter of record, more so when the very same convicts had contested the petition challenging the grant of remission to them?
• Why were repeated adjournments taken by the petitioners in a matter of this sort, where long incarceration and the health status of the petitioners are the primary grounds for seeking suspension of sentence? Was this a case of bench-hunting, making the adjournments suspect?
• Why was the fact that the remission of these convicts was cancelled by a Bench of Justices Nagarathna and Bhuyan not brought to the notice of the Bench of Justices Sundresh and Varale, which suspended their sentences?
• Why was the matter not posted before the same Bench which had earlier had occasion to hear the matter concerning the grant of remission to these two convicts?
Meanwhile over 500 feminists, activists, academics, lawyers, writers, artists, students and concerned citizens from different walks of life have endorsed an open letter to Bilkis Bano, expressing outrage over the Supreme Court decision to suspend the life sentences of two convicts.
The open letter condemns the fact that Bilkis Bano, a woman who has already spent twenty-four years fighting for justice can once again be forced to confront fear, insecurity and trauma, and compelled to seek justice again and again.
“Despite all the rhetoric of ‘Nari Shakti’, this moment sets back years of struggle in the life of every Bilkis Bano in the country and emboldens those who commit such crimes to continue to do so with impunity.”, the letter says.
The letter adds “Bilkis Bano's struggle is inseparable from the wider fight against communal hatred, patriarchal violence and the erosion of constitutional protections. It draws attention to the increasingly precarious position of Muslims in India, whose citizenship, dignity and constitutional rights are repeatedly called into question.”
Among the signatories are:
Women and gender rights activists and academics: Uma Chakravarti, Dr. Ruth Manorama, Sujata Surepally, Annie Raja, Nivedita Menon, Kalpana Kannabiran, Kalyani Menon Sen, Kavita Srivastava, Maimoona Mollah, Meera Sanghamitra, A Suneetha, Vani Subramanian, Anuradha Banerji, Bittu Kr, Navsharan Singh, Shabnam Hashmi, Dr Chayanika Shah, Ammu Abraham, Sandhya Gokhale, Shals Mahajan, Mridul Dudeja, Hasina Khan, Maivash Sayed, Madhu Bhushan, Sarojini N, Mary E John, J Devika, Dr. Sylvia Karpagam, Vanita Mukherjee, Mario da Penha, Mumtaz Beegum TL , Arundhati Dhuru, Megha Pansare, Rehana Murdsal, Meena Seshu, Tanuja Shirpurkar, Manjushree Pawar, Lara Jesani, Poonam Kaushik, Antara Dev Sen, Sejal Dand, Anuradha kapoor, Nalini Nayak, Dev Desai, Dr. Amrita Chhachhi, Rita Manchanda, Anu Chenoy, Roshmi Goswami, Dr Ajita Rao, Ritu Menon, Rajashri Dasgupta, Cedric Prakash, Anjali Bhardwaj, Mariam Dhawale, Kavita Panjabi, Mridula Mukherjee, Nandini Sundar, Raynah Marise, Enakshi Ganguly, Karen Gabriel, Pratiksha Baxi, Rinchin, Rajim Thandi, Sabina Martins, Sadhna Arya, Satnam Kaur, Savita Sharma, among others
Journalists: Revati Laul, Rajashri Dasgupta, Namita Bhandare, Laxmi Murthy, Geeta Seshu, among others.
Filmmakers/Artists etc: Prakash Raj, Anand Patwardhan, Teena Gill, Maya Rao, Sheba Chhachhi, Anjali Montiero, Leena Manimekalai, Farha Khatun, Gurpreet Kaur Sidhu, Priya Sen, Jabeen Merchant, Shabani Hassanwalia, Shuddhabrata Sengupta, among others
Groups and Networks: Saheli Women’s Resource Centre, ALIFA-NAPM (All India Feminist Alliance), Forum Against Oppression of Women, Hasrat e Zindagi Mamuli, National Federation of Dalit Women, Althea, Pragatisheel Mahila Sangathan (PMS), Gujarat Mahila Manch, ANHAD, Sangat, Dalit Women’s Collective, All India Democratic Women’s Association (AIDWA), Indian Christian Women's Movement, SAMATA Progressive Women's Organisation, Feminists in Resistance, Bailancho Saad, Naveddu Nilladiddare(NND), Chattisgarh Mahila Adhikar Manch among others